2021 News & Events

Ocean life helps produce clouds, but existing clouds keep new ones at bay

12 October 2021
adapted from the story by University of Wisconsin - Madison

marine boundary layer
The view from the NASA DC-8 research aircraft as it flies through the marine boundary layer, the portion of the atmosphere close to the ocean's surface where the ocean affects processes like cloud formation. Photo: Samuel R. Hall, NCAR

Stand on the ocean's shore and take a big whiff of the salt spray and you'll smell the unmistakably pungent scent of the sea. That ripe, almost rotting smell? That's sulfur. Marine plankton breathe more than 20 million tons of sulfur into the air every year, mostly in the form of dimethyl sulfide (DMS). In the air, this chemical can transform into sulfuric acid, which helps produce clouds by giving a site for water droplets to form. Over the scale of the world's oceans, this process affects the entire climate.

But new research from the University of Wisconsin–Madison (UW-Madison), NOAA CSL and others reveals that more than one-third of DMS can never help new clouds form because it is lost to the clouds themselves. Before DMS can turn into sulfuric acid, it takes the form of a newly identified molecule known as HPMTF (hydroperoxymethyl thioformate). HPMTF dissolves in cloud droplets, reducing the amount of sulfur that can eventually produce clouds.

The new findings significantly alter the prevailing understanding of how marine life influences clouds. And the research will likely change how scientists predict how cloud formation responds to changes in the oceans. By reflecting sunlight back into space and controlling rainfall, clouds play significant roles in the global climate. Accurately predicting them is essential to understanding the effects of climate change.

"It turns out that this story of cloud formation was really incomplete," says Tim Bertram, a UW–Madison professor of chemistry and senior author of the new report. "Over the last three or four years, we've been questioning parts of that story, both through laboratory experiments and with large-scale field experiments. Now we can better connect the dots between what's emitted from the ocean and how you form these particulates that encourage cloud formation."

Gordon Novak
Lead author Gordon Novak in the lab with the NOAA iodide ion time-of-flight chemical ionization mass spectrometer (CIMS) instrument.

With collaborators from 13 other institutions, Gordon Novak, a graduate student at UW-Madison, now a CIRES researcher at CSL, constructed the analysis published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

A few years ago, this group of collaborators, led by Patrick Veres at CSL, discovered that on its way to becoming sulfuric acid, DMS first turns into HPMTF, an intermediate molecule that had never been identified before. For the new study, the team used NASA-owned, instrument-laden aircraft to capture detailed measurements of these chemicals over the open ocean both inside of clouds and under sunny skies.

"This is a massive DC-8 aircraft. It's a flying laboratory. Essentially all of the seats have been removed, and very precise chemical instrumentation has been put in that allows the team to measure, at very low concentrations, both the emitted molecules in the atmosphere and all of the chemical intermediates," says Bertram.

From the flight data, the team discovered that HPMTF readily dissolves into the water droplets of clouds, which permanently removes that sulfur from the cloud nucleation process. In cloud-free areas, more HPMTF survives to become sulfuric acid and help form clouds.

Led by collaborators from Florida State University, the team accounted for these new measurements in a large, global model of ocean atmospheric chemistry. They discovered than 36% of the sulfur from DMS is lost to clouds in this way. On top of another 15% of sulfur lost through other processes, the upshot is that less than half of the sulfur marine plankton release as DMS can help nucleate clouds.

"This loss of sulfur to the clouds reduces the formation rate of small particles, so it reduces the formation rate of the cloud nuclei themselves. The impact on cloud brightness and other properties will have to be explored in the future," says Bertram.

Until recently, researchers have largely ignored the effects clouds have on chemical processes over the ocean, in part because it is difficult to obtain good data from the cloud layer. But the new study shows both the power of the right instruments to get that data and the significant roles clouds can play, even influencing the processes that give rise to the clouds themselves.

"This work has really reopened this area of marine chemistry," says Bertram.

Novak, G.A., C.H. Fite, C.D. Holmes, P.R. Veres, J.A. Neuman, I. Faloona, J.A. Thornton, G.M. Wolfe, M.P. Vermeuel, C.M. Jernigan, J. Peischel, T.B. Ryerson, C.R. Thompson, I. Bourgeois, C. Warneke, G.I. Gkatzelis, M.M. Coggon, K. Sekimoto, T.P. Bui, J. Dean-Day, G.S. Diskin, R.H. Moore, E.B. Wiggins, E.L. Winstead, C. Robinson, L. Thornhill, K.J. Sanchez, S. Hall, K. Ullmann, D. Blake, and T.H. Bertram, Rapid cloud removal of dimethyl sulfide oxidation products limits SO2 and cloud condensation nuclei production in the marine atmosphere, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, doi:, 2021.

Abstract

Oceans emit large quantities of dimethyl sulfide (DMS) to the marine atmosphere. The oxidation of DMS leads to the formation and growth of cloud condensation nuclei (CCN) with consequent effects on Earth's radiation balance and climate. Quantitative assessment of the impact of DMS emissions on CCN concentrations necessitates a detailed description of the oxidation of DMS in the presence of existing aerosol particles and clouds. In the unpolluted marine atmosphere, DMS is efficiently oxidized to hydroperoxymethyl thioformate (HPMTF), a stable intermediate in the chemical trajectory towards sulfur dioxide (SO2) and ultimately sulfate aerosol (Veres et al. 2020). Using direct airborne flux measurements, we demonstrate that irreversible loss of HPMTF to clouds in the marine boundary layer determines the HPMTF lifetime (t(HPMTF) < 2 hours) and terminates DMS oxidation to SO2 in the cloudy marine boundary layer. When accounting for HPMTF cloud loss in a global chemical transport model, we show that SO2 production from DMS is reduced by 35% globally and near surface (0-3km) SO2 concentrations over the ocean are lowered by 24%. This large, previously unconsidered loss process for volatile sulfur accelerates the timescale for conversion of DMS to sulfate, while limiting new particle formation in the marine atmosphere and changing the dynamics of aerosol growth. This loss process potentially reduces the spatial scale over which DMS emissions contribute to aerosol production and growth and weakens the link between DMS emission and marine CCN production with subsequent impacts on cloud formation, radiative forcing, and climate.